So if protagonists can be both good and bad people, are there any qualities they should have? The answer is yes: protagonists must be in some way likable and interesting to us as an audience. But what exactly constitutes as characters who have these qualities? Well, I've found a good basic place to start is the moral alignment chart made famous by Dungeons & Dragons:
(by Dogpersonthing @ http://dogpersonthing.deviantart.com/art/Blank-Alignment-Chart-413418733)
Generally, when crafting a character, try to place their general attitude in one of these nine basic categories. It should give one a basic place to start when examining how your characters will behave in a given situation. For example, if my protagonist Enoch the Greater was of the Lawful Good alignment and came across a weary escaped prisoner, it would be of Enoch's alignment to help the prisoner until he was once again ready to serve for his crimes. However, this could lead to some interesting dilemmas internally with Enoch. He may want the prisoner to stay free if he doesn't seem like such a bad man. Alternatively, he may be taken advantage of by the prisoner, and come to regret his decision to nurse him back to health. All of these scenarios place Enoch in a relatable light that gives us emotional investment with him. It's worth noting that, while the alignment chart is a good place to start, it is not necessarily the end-all, do-all for a particular character's, especially a protagonist's, decisions in a story.
Another important idea to keep in mind while writing protagonists is that of Jason Campbell's hero's journey. In a hero's journey, the character grows as a person in regards to the general plot of the tale.
For example, if my protagonist, John Redhelm, is called to kill the dragon terrorizing the Northern villages, he would find himself at the beginning of his own heroic journey. The amazing thing about Campbell's theory is that it is applicable to not only nearly all ancient stories and legends but also many modern day ones as well. If writing a protagonist and how the plot unfolds for him/her is becoming difficult for you, you could always just step back and see if Campbell could help you out in some way.
Next week, I'll be taking a look at the opposite of the protagonist - the antagonist. From there we'll be examining three dimensional characters, plot conventions, tropes, setting and so forth. Thanks for reading and see you next week!
Hi Patrick,
ReplyDeleteThis was interesting to read! It gave me a new perspective I didn't previously have...when I was in high school I was taught that the protagonist was the "good guy" in the story. And by the way, last week I saw A Clockwork Orange for the first time. VERY messed up movie! But I see your point about Alex.
But I wonder...can there be more than one protagonist in a story? What if you have a ton of characters, and the story isn't just centered around one? For example, if you have seen the show Game of Thrones, there are so many characters and so many you feel pity for, or "want to succeed". How would you classify thos characters?
I enjoyed reading this!